The use and cost‐effectiveness of intraoperative navigation in pediatric sinus surgery

The use and cost‐effectiveness of intraoperative navigation in pediatric sinus surgery:

Objectives/Hypothesis

There are consensus statements about when to use intraoperative navigation (IN) in adult sinus surgery. However, no corresponding guidelines exist for pediatrics. Our objectives included: 1) assess the demographic and operative factors associated with IN use and 2) calculate the cost‐effectiveness of IN use.

Study Design

Retrospective chart review.

Methods

One hundred nineteen pediatric patients undergoing sinus surgery between 2003 and 2016 were reviewed. Demographic and surgical factors were collected from medical records. Costs associated with use of IN were gathered from billing records.

Results

Of the 119 patients, 60 underwent sinus surgery with navigation (wIN) and 59 underwent surgery without navigation (sIN). Children in the wIN group had more complex surgeries with more sinuses opened (P = .008). Individual attending surgeon and presence of trainee were associated with increased use of IN (P < .001 for both). IN resulted in a median of 31.5 minutes longer surgical time (P < .001). IN had an incremental cost/effectiveness ratio (ICER) of $22,378 for each year without revision surgery for patients with acute disease. However, for patients with chronic disease, the probability of undergoing a second surgery was the same between wIN and sIN groups, and navigation was not cost‐effective (ICER of −$3,583).

Conclusions

IN use did not decrease complications or rates of revision surgery. It was used primarily as an educational tool or to increase confidence in intraoperative identification of landmarks. However, the use of IN added surgical time and was not cost‐effective. Further research must be completed to determine when IN is indicated in pediatric sinus surgery.

Level of Evidence

4

Laryngoscope, 2019